Ep 221: RANKed: Best Bathroom Cereal

Listen to episode 221 here, or wherever you get your podcasts.

 

Background to a Balanced Breakfast

Before we get to our ranked, it would do well to give some background as it relates to the bathroom.

Back when we talked about enemas, we took a stop at the Battle Creek Sanitarium. In the 1800s the typical breakfast consisted of a very heavy diet. Meat, potatoes, steak and eggs. Pancakes and sausage. It honestly sounds like a great time. That was the norm. A big and hearty breakfast, often very fatty and greasy, to get you through the work day.

While this breakfast cannot be blamed entirely for the health concerns which were rampant during the time, they nonetheless were a factor. There were a number of people who had TB, and other health concerns. One of these ongoing health concerns was dyspepsia. While this began to pop up heavily during and coming out of the civil war era, there was a widespread struggle with dyspepsia. If you have never heard of dyspepsia, neither had I. In short, it is just severe indigestion and nausea. Pretty much any of the ailments that Pepto Bismol will cover, is pretty  much what dyspepsia is all about.

When you’re eating a bunch of fatty foods, first thing in the morning, it’s no wonder that the heart burn furnace has been fired up by noon and stays lit all day. No tums in sight, no pepto. What are we supposed to do?

There had been some who had sought to break away from these breakfast norms. Dr James Caleb Jackson invented a healthy breakfast food called granula, this was served at his health spa, turns out Kellogg wasn’t the only one up to this at the time. It consisted of dense nuggets or “wheat rocks” and required overnight soaking. The belief was this healthier option would help the tummy and help the rest of your body. It was not considered a breakfast item as it was marketed as a health or medicinal product to alleviate stomach trouble.

The healthy breakfast grains soaked in stuff trend  was seemingly catching on.

This takes us back to Battle Creek. While The Kellogg's brothers were giving yogurt enemas and calling for 4-5 bowel movements a day, they were also proponents of healthy living based on their Seventh Day Adventist ties. This belief would lead them to denounce the fatty meat laden breakfasts that were so common for a different alternative. It wasn’t yogurt, they shoved that up your butt.

Rather, in 1877 Dr Kellogg concocted his own twice baked mix of flour, oats, and cornmeal that after some broken teeth from Sanitarium goers and trial and error, he began to bake into small pieces for serving. This was an early version of the corn flake. The background story for cornflakes is as varied as the flavors of cinnamon toast crunch in the year 2026… Most accounts note that after accidentally leaving some of this mixture out overnight in 1898, not wanting to waste it after it had dried, they broke off the flakes and ate them.

Another contribution Kellogg’s gave to the bathroom and bathroom adjacent at the time include: The “chewing song” which was designed and intended to encourage good and appropriate chewing for one’s health. Yet another was having his brother dictate for him while he took a dump. With all this fiber, he didn’t want to stop working in order to poop, so little bro had to stand there and write down his thoughts while he pooped.

I want to say, this is so great. It’s like a pre modern day recording version of shower or toilet thoughts. 

Last, as we have discussed his famous 15 quart yogurt enemas. That’s a lot of water, and admittedly too much yogurt.

His brother took the rights to the cereal and struck out on his own, leaving the Sanitarium and butt yogurt behind. He founded the Battle Creek Corn Flake Company. Really on the nose with that. In 1906. He tweaked the recipe and began manufacturing Kellogg’s Corn Flakes. While there have been grains and oats eaten for centuries prior by many cultures. He became successful, selling 120,000 cases a day in 1909. John didn’t like his brother’s success and sued him for the rights to the Kellogg name, but the Michigan supreme court settled in Will’s favor, a win for Corn Flakes.

But, Kellogg wasn’t the only one with cereal on the brain.

Part of a Competitive Breakfast

CW post visited the Battle Creek Sanitarium in the late 1800s. While there he was treated to a strange, crispy, flaky food that was reported to help his tummy feel better. Seeing Kellogg’s success, he set out to do the same, adapting the corn flakes in a mass produced version, grape nuts.

Prior to this endeavor, he invented something called Postum which is roasted wheat and molasses. Post struggled from a life of stomach issues and having benefited from the health offered at Sanitariums like Battle Creek, he decided to come up with something to help. Things didn’t take off with postum, and his grape nuts released two years later in 1897. In 1904, he released Post Toasties, originally called Elijah’s mannah.

At the turn of the century the popularity of this dried grain or corn based product was catching on and there were somewhere around 40 different cereal brands. With competition was differences in style. Puffed rice, puffed corn, shredded wheats, and some mild flavoring and sweetening occurred. This was all to continue to help people choose cereal as a healthier option to alleviate what was decades long bathroom troubles.

In the early days of cereal, in the face of the greasy and high fat breakfasts available, these whole grains and other breakfast cereal options probably did a lot of good. But, in the 1940’s a shift occurred. Kellogg is notorious for not wanting his flakes to have sugar, one of the reasons the brothers parted ways. But in 1939, something happened in the cereal market as a whole. Ranger Joe Popped Wheat Honnies released and are regarded as the first “sugar” cereal. From there, a slide away from health and into flavor occurred.

Why? Money. Standing on business as it relates to health and pooping, doesn’t pay the bill when you have new flavors and sugar blasted tooty ohs on the market to compete with. What was once a healthy food with your tummy in mind, kind of became a snack and a dessert really.

We’ve discussed some in the past about the times cereal has put people in the bathroom. First, fiber. Second, food dyes. These are culprits putting the cereal aisle in the bathroom. But, what if we return the cereal to the bathroom origins. Not to get you pooping, but as an accompaniment of pooping.

Part of a Bathroom Breakfast

To test the cereal contestants, there were 4 tests: Toilet Snack (how is it while eaten on the toilet), Shower cereal (how is it when eaten with hot water in the shower), Pee training (how is it aiming at while you pee), Soggy Bottom (how does it hold up under an average poop’s time sitting in milk?

We had 12 contestants with the standings as follows:

Cheerios 14
Toilet Snack. - 4
Shower cereal - 2
Pee training. - 6
Soggy bottom - 2

Honey Nut cheerios 22
Toilet Snack.  - 8
Shower cereal - 4 
Pee training. - 6
Soggy bottom - 4

Cinnamon Toast Crunch 26 (2nd Place)
Toilet Snack. - 7
Shower cereal - 6
Pee training. - 9 
Soggy bottom - 4

Coco Pebbles 16
Toilet Snack.  6
Shower cereal 6
Pee training. 2 
Soggy bottom 2 

Golden Crisp 24 (3rd place TIE)
Toilet Snack. 8
Shower cereal 7 
Pee training. 5
Soggy bottom 4

Resse’s Puffs 22
Toilet Snack. 7
Shower cereal 3
Pee training. 6
Soggy bottom 6

Frosted Flakes  17
Toilet Snack.  6
Shower cereal 5
Pee training. 5
Soggy bottom 1

Fruity Pebbles 15
Toilet Snack. 6
Shower cereal 5
Pee training. 3
Soggy bottom 1

Froot Loops 18
Toilet Snack. 5
Shower cereal 2
Pee training. 7
Soggy bottom 4

Lucky Charms 24 (3rd place TIE)
Toilet Snack.  6
Shower cereal 7 
Pee training. 5
Soggy bottom 6

Honeycomb 20
Toilet Snack. 5
Shower cereal 3
Pee training. 9
Soggy bottom 3

Captain Crunch 29 (1st Place)
Toilet Snack. 8
Shower cereal 8 
Pee training. 5
Soggy bottom 8

Sources:

https://www.history.com/articles/cereal-breakfast-origins-kellogg

https://www.mashed.com/234648/the-real-reason-breakfast-cereal-was-invented/

https://www.pbs.org/food/stories/history-of-cereal

Next
Next

Ep 220: Panchagavya